Master the Long Island Iced Coffee: Your Ultimate Guide to This Boozy Brew
Prepare to elevate your cocktail game with this extraordinary Long Island Iced Coffee, a sophisticated and utterly delicious twist on the famed Long Island Iced Tea. While the original cocktail is legendary for packing a hidden punch without any actual tea, this innovative version brings the rich, invigorating depth of coffee into the mix. It’s a remarkably versatile drink, offering two distinct paths depending on your preference for potency and flavor profile. Whether you prefer a slightly milder, coffee-forward experience or a robust, full-strength kick, this recipe has you covered. Imagine swapping your traditional Irish coffee with a perfectly chilled, complex, and deeply satisfying alternative – this is it. It’s an adult coffee drink that perfectly bridges the gap between a morning pick-me-up and an evening indulgence, ideal for any season or celebration.
Why You’ll Absolutely Love This Boozy Coffee Cocktail
Long Island Iced Teas often evoke images of warm summer nights, but what if you crave that distinct, spirited flavor during cooler months or simply enjoy coffee more than cola? This Long Island Iced Coffee offers the perfect solution! It takes the beloved concept of its predecessor and infuses it with the aromatic, comforting notes of coffee, creating a unique and deeply satisfying boozy coffee drink that transcends seasonal boundaries.
Just like the classic, this iced coffee cocktail doesn’t shy away from a potent combination, featuring up to five different alcohol varieties. The beauty of this recipe lies in how seamlessly the rich coffee flavor blends with the spirits, creating a surprisingly smooth drink where the alcohol is present but exceptionally well-integrated. You get all the celebratory spirit without an overpowering alcohol taste.
We’re providing you with recipes for both a stronger, more traditional spirit-focused version and a slightly milder, more coffee-complementing iteration. This flexibility allows you to tailor the drink to your exact taste and desired strength. Even the “weaker” version is still a wonderfully strong cocktail, making it an ideal treat to enjoy responsibly at home. While traditionally served cold, you could certainly experiment with a warm version, though we recommend choosing liquors that specifically enhance coffee notes for that experience.
Beyond being a fantastic winter warmer or a refreshing summer sipper, this Long Island Iced Coffee cocktail is a fantastic alternative to the classic Irish coffee. It offers a similar depth of flavor but with a more complex and diverse alcohol profile. It pairs beautifully with a wide array of sweet treats, making it the perfect adult beverage for special occasions or simply unwinding at the end of a long day.
Quick + Easy Recipes
straight to your inbox
Long Island Iced Coffee: Detailed Ingredients List
This recipe provides a balanced blend of flavors that perfectly complement the coffee base. This is our recommended, slightly “weaker” (yet still potent!) version focused on harmonious coffee-friendly liqueurs:
- 2 ounces cold brew (or any strong, chilled coffee)
- ½ ounce amaretto liquor (for a sweet almond note)
- ½ ounce creme de cacao (adds a delightful chocolate essence)
- ½ ounce butterscotch schnapps (for a rich, creamy, caramel-like sweetness)
- ½ ounce Bailey’s Irish cream (any flavor; caramel is particularly excellent for a smooth, creamy finish)
- ½ ounce hazelnut liquor (such as Frangelico, contributing a nutty depth)
- Plenty of ice cubes
Ingredient Notes & Flavor Customization
One of the best aspects of this Long Island Iced Coffee recipe is its adaptability. Feel free to substitute any liquors you don’t prefer or don’t have on hand. For a continued coffee-centric flavor profile, excellent choices include Kahlua (a classic coffee liqueur), Amarula (cream liqueur with fruit notes), or RumChata (creamy rum liqueur with cinnamon and vanilla). If you’re looking for a fruity twist, Chambord offers a wonderful raspberry kick, or opt for triple sec to introduce a bright orange flavor. The goal is to build a complex, layered flavor that dances beautifully with the coffee.
Stronger Alternate Recipe (Classic Long Island Spirit Profile)
For those who desire the full strength and traditional spirit blend reminiscent of a classic Long Island Iced Tea, simply swap the coffee-friendly liqueurs for this robust combination:
- 2 ounces cold brew (or cold coffee)
- ½ ounce Bailey’s Irish cream (any flavor, for creaminess)
- ½ ounce Kahlua (or another coffee liquor like Tia Maria for enhanced coffee flavor)
- ½ ounce white rum (or dark rum for a deeper note)
- ½ ounce vodka (a neutral base for the punch)
- ½ ounce tequila (for that unmistakable kick)
- Plenty of ice cubes
Substitution Notes for the Stronger Version: This version is also quite flexible. You can use gin or brandy to replace any of the listed liquors if you have a preference or are missing an ingredient. If you wish to maintain this strong ingredient set but prefer a slightly milder drink, simply add a splash of half and half, milk, or your favorite coffee creamer. This will dilute the alcohol content slightly while adding a lovely creamy texture and mellowing the overall intensity.
How to Craft Your Perfect Long Island Iced Coffee at Home
Making this incredible boozy coffee drink is surprisingly simple, requiring just a few easy steps:
- Combine all ingredients in a cocktail shaker: Pour the cold brew (or cold coffee), all your chosen liquors (from either the standard or stronger recipe), and a generous handful of ice cubes into a sturdy cocktail shaker. Ensure the lid is tightly sealed to prevent any spills during shaking.
- Shake vigorously until thoroughly chilled and mixed: Shake the cocktail shaker for approximately 30 seconds. You’ll feel the exterior of the shaker become frosty and cold. This ensures all the spirits are well combined with the coffee and properly chilled, creating a smooth, integrated flavor.
- Strain into your serving glass: Place a strainer over a whiskey glass (or any similar sturdy glass) that’s already filled with fresh ice. Pour the well-shaken Long Island Iced Coffee directly over the ice, filling the glass to your desired level.
- Sip and enjoy responsibly! Your homemade Long Island Iced Coffee is now ready to be savored. Garnish with a coffee bean or a dash of chocolate shavings for an extra touch of elegance, if desired.
Perfect Pairings: What to Serve With a Long Island Iced Coffee
This boozy coffee cocktail is a true dessert in a glass, making it an ideal companion for a wide variety of sweet treats. The rich coffee and creamy liqueur notes beautifully complement almost any dessert, turning an ordinary evening into an extraordinary one. Consider these delightful pairings:
- Baked Goods: Donuts, Cookies, Brownies, Muffins, Croissants, Scones, Biscotti (especially almond or chocolate dipped)
- Cakes & Pastries: Cake (chocolate, vanilla, or coffee-flavored), Cheesecake, Tiramisu, Crepes, Beignets
- Frozen Treats: Ice cream (vanilla, coffee, or caramel flavored)
- Simple Delights: Fresh Apples, Mixed Berries, High-quality Chocolate (dark or milk)
These pairings make for the perfect cap to any meal or a decadent indulgence on its own. For an especially harmonious match, try this iced coffee cocktail with our recipes for Caramel Toffee Scones, a rich Tiramisu Mug Cake, crispy Air Fryer Biscotti, flaky Frozen Croissants in the Air Fryer, decadent Air Fryer Double Chocolate Muffins, or a comforting Cinnabon Coffee Cake in the Air Fryer for an unforgettable experience.
Long Island Iced Coffee: Recipe FAQs
What Exactly Is a Long Island Iced Coffee?
A Long Island Iced Coffee is an innovative and spirited cocktail that ingeniously blends various liquors with cold brew coffee, traditionally served over ice. This enticing beverage typically features a combination of vodka, rum, tequila, and a selection of coffee-complementing liqueurs like Kahlua, Bailey’s Irish Cream, amaretto, or butterscotch schnapps.
It draws its name from the classic Long Island Iced Tea, a cocktail infamous for its strong alcohol content despite its innocent appearance and the absence of actual tea. The key distinction in the “iced coffee” version is the brilliant swap of cola for rich, cold brew coffee as the primary non-alcoholic base, transforming it into a luxurious, caffeinated adult drink that’s perfect for coffee lovers seeking a boozy treat.
Can I Customize the Ingredients in a Long Island Iced Coffee?
Absolutely! Customization is one of the most exciting aspects of making a Long Island Iced Coffee. In fact, the original Long Island Iced Tea’s liquor blend (vodka, gin, rum, tequila, triple sec) is often modified in the coffee version to better harmonize with coffee flavors.
The most popular alternative liqueurs that pair exceptionally well with coffee include Bailey’s Irish Cream, butterscotch schnapps, amaretto, hazelnut liquor (like Frangelico), and creme de cacao. You are encouraged to mix and match these, or swap in any spirits or liqueurs you prefer to create your own unique coffee cocktail. Additionally, you can adjust the sweetness or mellow the intensity by adding a splash of half and half, milk, or your favorite coffee creamer, making it a truly personalized adult beverage.
Is Long Island Iced Coffee as Strong as its Iced Tea Counterpart?
Yes, typically, a Long Island Iced Coffee can be just as strong as the classic Long Island Iced Tea. Both cocktails are renowned for their potent alcohol content, often featuring a blend of five different spirits. The fundamental difference lies in the base mixer: cold brew coffee in place of cola.
However, the Long Island Iced Coffee inherently offers greater versatility for adjusting strength and flavor. The robust nature of coffee pairs wonderfully with a broader range of creamy liqueurs and dairy products, allowing for easier customization. You can easily tweak the alcohol levels or dilute the drink with creams or milk to create a more subdued yet equally delicious coffee cocktail without sacrificing its unique character.
Is it Possible to Make a Non-Alcoholic Version of Long Island Iced Coffee?
Absolutely! You can effortlessly create a delicious non-alcoholic mocktail version of the Long Island Iced Coffee by simply omitting the spirits. To replicate the complex flavors and creamy texture without alcohol, replace the various liqueurs with an assortment of flavored coffee syrups. Excellent choices include caramel, hazelnut, butterscotch, chocolate, or amaretto syrups, which provide the desired sweetness and flavor depth.
For the creamy element that many alcoholic versions possess, incorporate a generous amount of half and half, milk, or your preferred coffee creamer. If you wish to avoid caffeine entirely, simply use decaffeinated coffee as your base. This allows everyone to enjoy the rich, layered taste of a Long Island Iced Coffee, regardless of their preference for alcohol or caffeine.
What Type of Glassware is Best for Serving Long Island Iced Coffee?
Long Island Iced Coffee is traditionally presented in a tall glass, such as a Collins glass or a highball glass, generously filled with ice. These types of glasses are ideal for showcasing the drink’s appealing layers and accommodating its volume, making for a visually striking presentation.
However, practicality often takes precedence, and almost any basic clear glass will suffice. Common alternatives include a pint glass, a can glass (for a modern touch), a classic whiskey or rocks glass, or any similar glassware you have readily available. The key is a clear glass that allows you to appreciate the rich color of this delightful coffee cocktail.
What Are Some Popular Variations of Long Island Iced Coffee?
The beauty of the Long Island Iced Coffee lies in its endless possibilities for variation, allowing you to tailor the flavor to your exact preferences. The most popular variations often involve swapping the traditional base spirits for a collection of liqueurs specifically chosen to enhance coffee notes. This frequently includes the delightful combination of Bailey’s Irish Cream, rich butterscotch schnapps, nutty amaretto, fragrant hazelnut liquor, and creamy creme de cacao.
Beyond this, you can experiment by mixing and matching different types of rum (light vs. dark), flavored vodkas, or even adding a hint of spiced liqueurs. Introducing flavored coffee syrups (like vanilla, caramel, or peppermint) or various coffee creamers can further adjust the flavor profile and modulate the strength, allowing you to craft a unique, signature coffee cocktail for any occasion.
Is Long Island Iced Coffee Served Hot or Cold?
Long Island Iced Coffee is predominantly served cold over ice, making it an incredibly refreshing and invigorating beverage. Its chilled nature is perfect for warmer weather, late afternoons, or as a spirited pick-me-up any time you desire a boozy coffee drink.
However, for a cozy and comforting experience, you can absolutely serve it hot! Simply omit the ice and use freshly brewed hot coffee as your base instead of cold brew. This transforms the cocktail into a warm, inviting adult drink, ideal for chilly days or as an after-dinner digestif, offering a delightful twist on the traditional presentation.
Recipe Pro Tips for the Best Long Island Iced Coffee
To ensure your Long Island Iced Coffee turns out perfectly every time, keep these expert tips in mind:
- Accurate Measurement Made Easy: If you don’t have a specialized liquid measuring cup or a jigger, remember that ½ fluid ounce is precisely equivalent to 1 Tablespoon. This simple conversion makes measuring out the various liquors much easier and ensures consistent results for your cocktail.
- Cocktail Shaker Alternatives: While a cocktail shaker is ideal for achieving a perfectly chilled and emulsified drink, don’t let its absence deter you. A mason jar or any container with a tight-fitting lid can serve as an excellent substitute. For the best outcome, shaking is highly recommended, especially when using creamy liqueurs like Bailey’s. Shaking helps to thoroughly mix the ingredients and prevents the cream from separating, which tends to happen more quickly if simply stirred into the coffee.
Storage and Serving Tips for Long Island Iced Coffee
Whether you’re making a single serving or preparing for a gathering, these tips will help you manage and present your Long Island Iced Coffee with ease:
- Scaling for Parties: This Long Island Iced Coffee recipe is wonderfully adaptable for larger groups. You can easily mix all the liquid ingredients (cold brew and spirits) ahead of time in a pitcher, making sure to omit the ice. This pre-mixed base can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 48 hours. When it’s time to serve, simply give the pitcher a good stir or a quick shake (if using a sealed container), then pour the mixture over ice into individual glasses. This method allows for quick and effortless serving, so you can enjoy your guests’ company without being stuck behind the bar.
- Choosing the Right Glassware: Don’t stress over having specific cocktail glasses. Any clear glass will work perfectly for serving this drink. While we often use 11-ounce whiskey glasses for their classic appeal, feel free to use highball glasses, pint glasses, can glasses, Collins glasses, or any other type of clear glass you have on hand. The important thing is to have a vessel that comfortably holds the drink and ice, allowing you to appreciate its beautiful dark hue.
More Delightful Coffee-Based Drinks
Pink Polar Bear Cocktail: Your Perfect Winter Mixed Drink
Crown Royal Salted Caramel White Russian: Sip in Style!
How to Make Coffee in the Microwave w/ Fresh Ground Coffee
- Butterscotch White Russian
- White Russian Daiquiri
- Peppermint Mudslide
Final Thoughts on This Unforgettable Iced Coffee Cocktail
This Long Island Iced Coffee is far more than just a cocktail; it’s a delightful reinvention of a classic, where the bold, aromatic character of coffee takes center stage, replacing the traditional cola. It offers a fresh perspective on a beloved boozy drink, providing both familiarity and an exciting new flavor experience.
While you can certainly prepare it with the conventional five-spirit blend of the original Long Island Iced Tea, we firmly believe its true potential shines when you select liquors that beautifully complement the coffee flavor. Imagine the harmonious notes of chocolate, creamy butterscotch, sweet caramel, luxurious Irish cream, and nutty amaretto dancing together with your favorite cold brew. This creates a sophisticated, multi-layered coffee cocktail that truly stands out.
We encourage you to experiment and mix and match to discover your own perfect iced coffee cocktail recipe. Don’t be afraid to adjust the ratios or try new liqueurs. The coffee itself does an excellent job of mellowing the potency of the alcohol, but if you prefer a gentler drink, a splash of half and half, milk, or coffee creamer will subtly tone things down without compromising on flavor.
This versatile Long Island Iced Coffee can be enjoyed year-round, pairing exquisitely with your favorite desserts. It’s an impeccable choice for festive occasions like New Year’s celebrations, or as a spirited alternative to a hot Irish coffee for St. Patrick’s Day. Ultimately, the perfect occasion is whenever you desire a truly exceptional adult coffee drink. Cheers to your next delightful sip!
Long Island Iced Coffee Recipe
Equipment
-
Liquid measuring cup (or a Tablespoon)
-
Shaker (or a mason jar)
-
Whiskey glass (or similar)
Ingredients
- 2 Ounces cold brew (or cold coffee)
- ½ Ounce amaretto liquor
- ½ Ounce creme de cacao
- ½ Ounce butterscotch schnapps
- ½ Ounce Bailey’s Irish cream (any flavor; I use caramel)
- ½ Ounce hazelnut liquor (such as Frangelico)
- Ice cubes
Instructions
-
Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker along with a few cubes of ice2 Ounces cold brew, ½ Ounce amaretto liquor, ½ Ounce creme de cacao, ½ Ounce butterscotch schnapps, ½ Ounce Bailey’s Irish cream, ½ Ounce hazelnut liquor, Ice cubes
-
Shake for about 30 seconds, until chilled and well mixed
-
Strain into a whiskey glass (or similar) filled with ice
-
Enjoy!
Notes
- You can substitute other complimentary liquors if there are any you don’t like or don’t have on hand. Kahlua, Amarula, and RumChata are great choices. Use Chambord for a raspberry twist or triple sec for an orange flavor option
- Stronger (classic) variation. Swap the listed alcohols out for ½ ounce each of Bailey’s Irish cream, Kahlua (or another coffee liquor like Tia Maria), white or dark rum, vodka, and tequila. You could also use gin or brandy in place of any of these liquors if you don’t like something or are missing an ingredient. If you want to make a weaker drink but use this ingredient set, add some half and half or coffee creamer to dilute it
- If you don’t have a liquid measuring cup, a ½ fluid ounce is equivalent to 1 Tablespoon (so feel free to use that if it’s easier)!
- In place of a cocktail shaker, use a mason jar or something similar. You can also just add all ingredients to a glass with ice and stir, but the Bailey’s separates even more so than it does when shaken so I do recommend shaking when possible
- This recipe scales well for parties. You can mix everything ahead of time in a pitcher (without ice) and store for up to 48 hours. Shake or stir, and then pour into individual ice-filled glasses to serve
- Any clear glasses are fine. I use 11-ounce whiskey glasses, but you can use highball, pint, can, Collins, or any other type of glass you have on hand
- Exact nutritional values will vary based on brand and flavor of ingredients, any swaps or additions, and actual quantity consumed, so please consider this a guideline only
Nutrition
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you try this recipe?
Mention @TheDinnersDoneQuick or tag #dinnersdonequick! for even more!
Pin Recipe
Leave A Review
